Learn/Accounting Firm Growth
Video article · Accounting Firm Growth

A ten-row scorecard for your accounting firm website

Score your firm website in ten minutes. One point per row for clarity, proof, pricing, niche pages and more, then pick one play to raise your score.

Rob SatromPublished November 15, 2026 · 5 min read
Quick answer

Most accounting websites try to be everything to everyone, so they say nothing. Ten rows and about ten minutes will tell you if yours is costing you clients. Eight or more is good shape. Under five means your site is likely losing business today.

1:24Watch the videoScore Your Accounting Firm Website in Ten Minutes

We made a matching video that covers the scorecard. This article goes through each row, the common mistakes and four ways to move your score.

The ten-row scorecard

Open your homepage in one window and this list in another. Give yourself one point for every row you can honestly say yes to.

  1. A clear first line. A stranger knows what you do.
  2. A headline that says who you help. A niche or a type of owner, not everyone.
  3. Proof. A Google rating or similar, visible near the top.
  4. A real person. A real portrait, not a stock photo.
  5. One obvious main button. The same wording all the way down.
  6. A second offer. Something for people who aren't ready to call.
  7. Pricing. A range, or a plain how-it-works page.
  8. Niche pages. At least one for an industry you want.
  9. Location pages. One for each area you serve.
  10. A phone number people can find. Without hunting.

Be strict. If you have to explain why a row counts, it doesn't.

What your score means

  • Eight to ten. You're in good shape. Fix what's missing and look at tracking.
  • Five to seven. You have a decent base, but gaps are costing you some clients.
  • Under five. Your site is probably costing you clients right now.

The common mistakes behind a low score

  • Talking to other CPAs instead of owners.
  • Stock photos.
  • Hidden pricing.
  • A contact form as the only way in.
  • Reviews on a page nobody visits.
  • One page for every service.

Most firms hit three or four of these. They're all fixable in a few weeks.

Four ways to move your score

You don't need to do all four. Pick the one that fits your firm and go deep.

1. Own your local market. Build pages for your city and nearby areas so people nearby see you first. Put your location in the first line.

2. Pick one industry niche. Speak to those owners directly. Show their problems, their software and their questions. A site that sounds like it was written for them wins over a generalist.

3. Offer a low-risk first step. A free analysis or a checklist for people who aren't ready to call. They give you an email, and you get a chance to follow up.

4. Go all in on transparency. Put your prices right on the homepage. It scares some buyers off, and that's fine. The ones who stay are ready.

A worked example

This is an illustration. Say a firm scores a 4. Their first line reads welcome. They have no photos of people, no prices, one page for all services and a contact form. Rows scored are phone number, a decent Google rating, a main button and a clear first line, barely.

They pick transparency and niche. In two weeks they change the headline to bookkeeping and tax planning for restaurants and add a price range. They add a real photo of the owner. They put a free restaurant cash flow review on the page as the second offer. Their score goes from 4 to 7 without touching location or the rest. One week later they build their first location page and hit 8.

Why niche pages beat a generalist site

An owner who runs a restaurant doesn't want a firm that does everything. They want one that knows restaurants. Niche pages say that out loud. They talk about the problems that industry has, the software they use and the questions they ask.

Start with one niche. Build a page that speaks to those owners in their words. Then link to it from your homepage and your service pages. If it works, build the next one.

Pricing and transparency

Many firms hide their prices because they're afraid of scaring people off. The ones who go the other way, with prices right on the homepage, tend to get calls from people who are ready. You filter out the wrong buyers early, and you spend your time on people who can say yes.

If you don't want to list exact prices, show a range and what's included. Add a line about how the process works in 20 seconds. That alone puts you ahead of most firms.

A lead magnet for people who aren't ready

Not every visitor is ready to book. Some are still deciding if they even need a new accountant. Give them something small to take. A short checklist, a free analysis or a one-page review all work. The best ones solve one problem for one type of owner, like a cash flow check for restaurants.

Ask for an email in return, then follow up with a short note a day or two later. Now you have a warm lead instead of a lost visitor.

The mistake to avoid

The mistake is trying all four plays at once. You end up doing each at half strength. Pick one, finish it, then pick the next.

Your Monday-morning list

  • Score yourself honestly on all ten rows.
  • Circle the lowest three.
  • Pick one of the four plays.
  • Rewrite your first line and headline today.
  • Add a real photo and your Google rating.
  • Put a price range on the page, even a wide one.

Want a second opinion on your score?

Book the $99 audit call with me. I'll look at your site the way a stranger would and tell you what I'd fix first. You'll walk away with your top three fixes. Book here: https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book

Questions people ask

How do I score my accounting firm's website?

Give yourself one point for each of ten rows you can honestly say yes to. The rows cover a clear first line, a headline about who you help, proof, a real person, one main button, a second offer, pricing, niche pages, location pages and a findable phone number.

What is a good score?

Eight or more out of ten means you're in good shape. Under five and your site is probably costing you clients right now.

What are the most common CPA website mistakes?

Talking to other CPAs, using stock photos, hiding pricing and offering only a contact form are the big ones. Putting reviews on a separate page and using one page for all services also hurt. Most firms hit three or four of these.

What is a lead magnet for a CPA firm?

It's a free resource for visitors who aren't ready to call, like a short checklist or a free analysis. It gives you a way to follow up. A good one solves one small problem for one type of owner.

Should a CPA firm show prices?

Hidden pricing is one of the most common mistakes. Showing prices, or at least a range, builds trust and filters out buyers who won't fit.

Rob Satrom
Rob Satrom, owner of Feedbackwrench

Rob built Feedbackwrench and Nuance Financial Tax & Accounting. Since 2015, our team has helped transform 550+ small businesses with marketing, strategy and systems.

Your next step

Want a second set of eyes on your marketing?

Book the $99 Sales & Marketing Audit. It's one live call with a scored look at your marketing and your top three fixes, in order. If nothing's broken, we'll tell you that too.