Most accountants think they're competing with the firm down the road. They aren't. The real competitor is inertia, because the owner's current person is doing fine. This lesson is for accountants and bookkeepers, and it shows you how to reveal what fine is costing without trashing anybody.
3:15Video almost liveYou're Up Against Fine
What you will learn
Why a prospect saying their current guy is fine is the hardest thing you'll ever try to beat. What fine is actually costing them, and how you show it without bad-mouthing anyone. And a 1 to 10 question you can ask on your very next call, word for word.
Why fine is such a strong enemy
Fine is powerful for three reasons.
- Fine costs nothing to keep. There's no pain, no invoice for the missed savings and nothing to change. Switching accountants, on the other hand, sounds like drilling your own forehead out.
- Fine has a face. Maybe it's their cousin, maybe a buddy from church. The whole thing feels personal, and nobody wants to be the person who dumped a family member.
- Fine means nothing's on fire yet. If nothing's burning, nobody goes shopping for a new accountant.
So you don't win by being slightly better. Slightly better doesn't beat free and familiar. You win by showing what fine is really costing them.
What fine hides
You'll find it in their returns and their books, so ask to see both. Three places to look first.
- The S corp they never elected. That one is usually where we find the money.
- Bonus depreciation taken at the wrong time, especially on trucks and equipment.
- Books nobody can make a decision from. If the owner can't answer a basic question about where the profit came from, that's a cost too.
Each of those is something the current person may be too busy or too meek to bring up. You aren't accusing anybody. You're just reporting what's on the page.
Add up the cost of fine
This is where it gets real. Use a number, and let it sit.
Say you've got a real estate agent making about 250K. An S corp, payroll and a solo 401k can save them around $8,000 a year. That's an example, and real savings depend on the situation.
Now let them stay with fine for 3 more years. Nobody calls that a decision. It just happens. That's $24,000 they never get back, and nobody ever sent them a bill for it.
That's the move. You're not saying their accountant is bad. You're saying what a few more years of nothing looks like, in dollars, from their own paperwork.
The 1 to 10 question
Start the conversation with this one. It's three steps.
- Ask it plain. On a scale of 1 to 10, are you getting proactive tax reduction planning right now?
- Let them pick a number. Then ask, are you a 10 out of 10, or more like a 1 out of 10?
- Tell them what's possible. If we adjusted your salary, you could save $5,000 right now. Can I do an analysis?
The question works because it hands the diagnosis to the owner. They pick the number. They hear the gap in their own voice.
What to say and what not to say
Don't say your current accountant is bad. Instead ask, "Fine as in nothing's on fire yet?" Then let them think about it. That one line gets you from small talk to the real conversation.
Don't say switch to me. Say, "I'm not here to replace anyone, and half the time I tell people to stay put." That lowers their guard, and it's honest. Sometimes the answer really is that they're in good shape.
Then show them a number from their own returns. A line I like, said with a smile, is, "I'll bet your accounting isn't a 10. I'll bet it's a 3. Let me show you." The smile matters. It keeps it friendly and curious.
A worked example
Call this an example, not a real call. You're at a networking event, and you meet a contractor who's been in business for several years. He says, "I've got an accountant. He's fine."
You say, "Fine as in nothing's on fire yet?"
He laughs. "Pretty much."
You ask the 1 to 10 question. "On a scale of 1 to 10, are you getting proactive tax reduction planning right now?"
He thinks. "Maybe a 4."
"Are you a 10 or more like a 1?"
"Closer to a 1, honestly."
You say, "I'm not here to replace anyone. Half the time I tell people to stay put. Can I look at your last two returns and your books and show you what I see? If it's a 10, I'll tell you."
That's the whole move. You didn't criticize his accountant, you didn't pitch and you didn't ask him to switch. You asked a question, gave him the pen and offered to look.
Why you can't win on price or polish
If you try to beat fine with a lower fee, you've turned a good conversation into a bidding war. And if you try to beat it with a slicker pitch, you've given the owner a reason to compare two sets of words. Neither one changes the situation.
What changes the situation is a specific finding. When the owner sees, in their own return, a missed S corp election or a depreciation choice that cost them money, the comparison is no longer between you and your competitor. It's between where they are today and where they could be. That's a much better place to be selling from.
It also explains why the analysis matters so much. It's the one tool that moves the owner from "fine" to "I didn't know." The next lessons cover how to run it. For now, remember the order. Ask the 1 to 10 question, let them pick a number and offer to look.
Questions to ask while you look
When you do get the returns and the books, you're listening for answers to a few simple questions.
- Is the business set up in a way that matches how much it earns?
- Is anyone planning ahead, or does the return get done after the year is over?
- Can the owner tell, from the books, which part of the business makes money?
You don't need to answer them all in the first meeting. You just need to find one real thing to show. One real thing from their own paperwork is worth more than a polished deck about what you do.
What to do on your next call
- Write the 1 to 10 question on a card and practice it out loud.
- Add the line, "Fine as in nothing's on fire yet?" to your list of responses to "I already have an accountant."
- Decide what three things you'll look for in the first returns you see.
- Practice one number from your own experience so you can show what fine costs over a few years.
The mistake to avoid
The mistake is going after the other accountant. You'll end up fighting family. Even if the other person is lazy, the owner is loyal, and loyalty beats logic more often than you'd think.
The other mistake is trying to win with a slightly better pitch. Fine costs nothing to keep, so a better pitch rarely moves it. A real number from their own returns does.
Want me to ask the 1 to 10 question about your marketing?
I've been doing this since 2015, and we've worked with over 550 businesses. If you want a second set of eyes on how you're showing up, I'll look at your marketing on the $99 audit call. Think of it as me asking the 1 to 10 question about your own marketing. Book it at https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book. You'll get a scored one-page audit, your top three fixes in order and what I'd do if it were my business.
Next in the course, the three villains every owner is living with, and how to name them without being nasty.
Questions people ask
What do I say when a prospect says they already have an accountant?
Don't say the current accountant is bad and don't say switch to me. Say, I'm not here to replace anyone, and half the time I tell people to stay put. Then offer to look at their returns and books and show them a number from their own paperwork.
Who is the real competitor of an accounting firm?
It isn't the firm down the road. It's inertia, because the owner's current person is doing fine. Fine costs nothing to keep, and switching accountants feels like a huge hassle.
What is the 1 to 10 question?
Ask, on a scale of 1 to 10, are you getting proactive tax reduction planning right now. Then ask whether they're a 10 out of 10 or more like a 1 out of 10. It lets them pick the number and hear their own gap.
What does fine hide in an owner's returns and books?
Look for an S corp they never elected, bonus depreciation taken at the wrong time on trucks and equipment, and books nobody can make a decision from. Those three are where I usually find the money.
How do I make fine feel expensive without trashing anyone?
Add it up using their own returns and books, then show what staying put costs over a few years. Nobody calls staying with fine a decision, it just happens. When the owner sees the total, the conversation changes without you saying anything bad about their accountant.





