Open your homepage and count how many times it says "we" and how many times it says "you." Most pages are all "we." Your customer is Luke, and you're Obi-Wan. The brain is wired to see itself as the hero, so if you grab that seat, your customer has nowhere to stand. Give them the hero seat and take the guide's seat.
1:38Watch the videoYour Customer Is Luke and You Are Obi-Wan
Why the "we" page doesn't work
Look at a typical homepage. Our awards. Our credentials. Our years of experience. Our team. All true, and all nearly invisible to a stranger, because they're busy thinking about their own problem.
Nobody lands on your site hoping to learn about you. They land because something's wrong, or they want something, and they're trying to figure out if you can help. When the page opens with your history, you've answered a question they didn't ask.
The two things a guide does, in order
Think about Obi-Wan. Before he asks Luke to do anything hard, he shows he understands. Then he shows he has the experience to lead.
1. Empathy first. Show them you've seen their exact situation and you know how it feels. Not "we care about our customers." That reads as fake. Name the situation and the feeling. "You've called three contractors and only one called back" does more than a mission statement.
2. Authority second. Something real. A year you started. A number of clients. A place. A real project.
Flip that order and you sound like you're boasting. Skip the feeling and "we care" sounds hollow.
What real authority sounds like
Use proof that can't be faked. Take mine. I say in business since 2015, not decades of experience. I say over 550 businesses, because a real number beats a vague one. And I built two businesses myself, Feedbackwrench and Nuance Financial Tax and Accounting.
Compare "decades of experience" to "in business since 2015." The second one is specific and checkable, and it sounds like someone who isn't trying to inflate anything.
How to flip your homepage
- Count. Tally every we, our, and us. Then every you and your. Be honest.
- Rewrite the first screen. Open with the customer's problem and how it feels. Use their words.
- Move your credentials down one step. After the empathy, add one real proof point.
- Check your headings. If you can, make most of them about the reader. A good target is for most headings to say you or your.
- Read it as a stranger. Does the page feel like it's about them?
A before and after
Here's an example, made up for illustration.
Before: "We're a full service remodeling company with a proud history of quality craftsmanship."
After: "You called three contractors and only one called back. We answer the phone, show up when we say, and send you an update every day."
The second one could be about a hundred different contractors, which is why you need to add your real specifics. But notice who's in the story. It's the customer. They can see themselves in it, and they keep reading.
Why the hero seat matters so much
People see their own life as a story, and they're the main character. When they read your page, they're quietly asking one thing. Is this about me?
If the answer is no, they leave. If the answer is yes, they stay and keep reading, because now they're in the story. You didn't need a clever design or a big budget to get that. You needed to change who the sentences are about.
That's also why a guide works. In a story, the hero doesn't need another hero. They need someone who has been down the road, who sees the problem clearly, and who offers a plan. That's your role.
What empathy sounds like in different businesses
These are examples to show the shape. Use your own customers' words.
- Bookkeeper. "You're a hardworking owner and you still can't tell what you made last month."
- Remodeler. "You've saved for this project, and you're afraid the budget will balloon."
- Accountant. "You keep hearing from your accountant once a year, in March."
None of these brag. All of them say, I see you. Then the authority comes in, in one line, and it feels earned.
Where else this shows up
The we versus you problem isn't only on your homepage. Check these places too.
- Your About page, which is often a long list of your own history.
- Your service pages, which sometimes describe your process before the customer's problem.
- Your ads, where the first line should be about them.
- Your email signature and bio, where one real proof point beats a paragraph.
The mistake to avoid
The most common mistake is treating "we" as a bad word and deleting all your proof. You need proof. It just can't come first, and it can't be vague.
The second mistake is faking empathy. "We understand how hard it is to run a business" could appear on anyone's site. If a line could appear on a competitor's page unchanged, it isn't doing the job.
Third, using too many credentials at once. One strong proof point beats a wall of badges.
Monday morning list
- Count the we and the you on your homepage.
- Rewrite the top of the page so it starts with their problem.
- Pick one real proof point and put it right after.
- Replace "decades of experience" type phrases with a real number or date.
- Ask someone outside your business to read it and tell you who the page is about.
If we wins, flip it. Open with their problem and how it feels, then add one real proof point. Now they see themselves on your page.
Want to know if your site makes you the hero or the guide? Book the $99 audit call with me at https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book. I'll read your site the way your customer does and tell you what to change. You leave with a scored one page audit and your top three fixes. If nothing's broken, I'll say so.
Questions people ask
What does it mean to be the guide and not the hero?
"In a good story, the hero is the one with the problem, and the guide helps them win. On your website, your customer is the hero and you're the guide. Your page should open with their problem, then show you understand it and can help."
Why does empathy come before authority?
"Authority first sounds like boasting. Empathy first shows you've seen their exact situation and you know how it feels, and then your credentials land as proof, not bragging."
How do I count we and you on my homepage?
"Open your homepage and count how many times it says we, our, and us. Then count you and your. If the we words win, rewrite the page so it starts with the customer's problem."
What counts as real authority?
"Specific, checkable things. A start year, a real number of clients helped, a real project, a real place. In business since 2015 beats decades of experience, and over 550 businesses beats lots of happy clients."
Should I remove my credentials from my website?
"No. Keep them, just put them second. Lead with the customer's problem and how it feels, then add one real proof point."





